Property Managers Take Note

2 Jul, 2014

In a recent decision of the Supreme Court of Appeal [1] a decision of the District Court of Queensland was upheld holding the owners of property liable for the ultimate death of a tradesman they had employed to undertake work at the property.

The case centered around a claim by the widow of the tradesman for loss of dependency as a result of the death of her husband from injuries sustained when he fell down a drainpipe on residential land at Indooroopilly.  The widow was awarded $445,000 damages in the first instance and this award was upheld on appeal.

The original decision of the District Court was based upon a finding that the owners of the property were negligent in failing to warn the tradesman about the existence of the drainpipe on the property.

As a result of the injuries suffered by the tradesman, he ultimately died.

Briefly the facts of the case were that the deceased tradesman had been employed by the owners of the property to undertake general gardening and lawn mowing services on their behalf. The incident the subject of the claim occurred while the deceased tradesman was trimming shrubbery in an area located behind a pool and adjacent to the rear boundary of the property. The tradesman whilst undertaking this task stepped onto an area where there was a drainage pipe over two metres deep which was covered by a metal lid which contained a metal grate. As he did so, the grate gave way and he fell two metres into the drainage pipe. From the evidence it appears that the steel grate had rusted over time. From the evidence it also appears that the area in question was overgrown with foliage and dead leaves.

As a result of the injuries suffered by the tradesman, he ultimately died. However, before he died, he had given instructions to his solicitors about the incident. He had advised his solicitors that he had not been told by the owners of the property about the existence of the drainage pipe or the metal grate.

The owners of the property purchased the property in 2007. When they purchased the property, they were made aware that there was a drainage easement running along the back of the property adjacent to the pool.

You May Also Like…

Contact Barclay MIS

Get in touch with the Barclay MIS team.

T: 1300 883 916
F: 1300 883 917

For over 35 years, Barclay MIS has been innovative in the field of debt recovery. We offer a range of products and services that utilises cutting edge technology that securely recover debt in accordance with legislation.

Copyright © 1985 - 2024 BARCLAY MIS. All Rights Reserved. ABN 79 096 963 692

Except as permitted by the copyright law applicable to you, you may not reproduce or communicate any of the content on this website, including files downloadable from this website, without the permission of the copyright owner.

Barclay MIS Protect & Collect Pty Ltd supports and encourages the dissemination and exchange of the information. However, copyright protects material on this website.

Although we have no objection to this material being reproduced, we assert the right to be recognised as author of our original material and to have our material remain unaltered.

Enquiries regarding the reproduction of our material may be directed to or telephone 1300 883 916.

Copyright of Barclay MIS Protect & Collect Pty Ltd’s materials resides with Barclay MIS Protect and Collect Pty Ltd. Apart from any fair dealings for the purposes of private study, research, criticism, or review as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced or re-used for any commercial or other purpose without written permission from our department.